Dismissal of Texas Supreme Court Justice’s Indictment Raises Questions


Decision not Unusual in Insurance Cases, Says Arson Investigations Expert


Jan. 23, 2008 - AUSTIN, TX The controversial case involving Texas Supreme Court Justice David Medina, a Harris County Grand Jury, and the Harris County District Attorney is raising a debate as to whether politics or a lack of evidence played a role in the dismissal of indictments against Judge Medina and his wife.

An expert arson investigator observes that the case highlights a situation that is not as unusual as some might expect: prosecutors declining to present what appears to be well-investigated arson or other insurance fraud related cases.

The decision could be based on a variety of circumstances, said Jim Whitaker, CFE, an adjunct faculty member who provides anti-fraud training for the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE). The ACFE is the premier provider of year-round training and education for anti-fraud professionals in more than 125 locations around the world.

Whitaker, who also formerly served as the Executive Director of the International Association of Arson Investigators (IAA), said that one scenario in a possible insurance fraud case might be a lack of evidence. “It is possible the elements needed to satisfy the statute for prosecution just aren’t there,” Whitaker said. “In that case, the prosecutor may want to wait until more evidence is uncovered before proceeding.”

Another possibility, said Whitaker, is that the name and stature of the defendant is influencing the case. “A prosecutor may simply decline to move forward on an insurance fraud case because of who the defendant is, either because of a lack of confidence in his/her ability to prosecute an arson/insurance fraud case, or because of some bias toward the defendant,” Whitaker said.

He added that such cases don’t often just go away after such a decision. The insurance carrier will conduct an investigation and take action if they feel it is warranted, regardless of what law enforcement does.

“The accused may still face a denial from the insurance carrier, and then it would most likely end up in civil court for disposition,” Whitaker said.

Jim Whitaker, CFE is available to the media for further comment on this developing story. Please contact Scott Patterson at (512) 478-9000, ext. 156, or email spatterson@acfe.com, to arrange an interview.

About the ACFE
With nearly 45,000 members in over 125 countries, the ACFE is the world’s premier anti-fraud association, providing knowledge and training used to reduce the occurrence of corporate fraud. Founded in 1988 by Joseph T. Wells, CFE, CPA, the ACFE has been identified as “the premier financial sleuthing organization” by The Wall Street Journal. The ACFE has been cited for its efforts against fraud by media such as U.S. News & World Report, The New York Times, CNN. CNBC, Fortune, ABC-TV’s Nightline and 20/20, and CBS News’ 60 Minutes.

For more information about the ACFE, visit www.ACFE.com.

Contact the ACFE
For more information, email PR@ACFE.com.



  • Avatar

    Thanks for this post. We customize each design so your personal preferences can make your tattoo unique and very personal to you.

  • Avatar

    Your website is so cool. I am impressed .
    http://www.aonesafepackers.in @ packers and movers pune
    http://www.aonesafepackers.in @ packers and movers in pune
    http://www.aonesafepackers.in @ movers and packers pune
    http://www.aonesafepackers.in @ movers and packers in pune
    http://www.aonesafepackers.in @ movers and packers

  • Avatar

    I was looking at some of your posts on this website and I conceive this web site is really instructive! Keep putting up.. http://www.healthcarejobsonline.co.uk/

  • Avatar

    Your website is so cool. I am impressed by the info that you have on this site. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. http://cflcharters.com

  • Avatar

    Its cool there is a site out there dedicated to fairness and equity for our youth. Hope more people create sites like this. <a href="http://cflcharters.com">new smyrna beach fishing charters</a>

  • Avatar

    But seriously though, try this recipe. It was the first time I tried it and it turned out great. You'll do fine too, I'm sure :) I'm rooting for you here! http://www.fishingdaytonabeach.com/

  • Avatar

    I just wanna thank you for sharing your information and your site or blog this is simple but nice article I have ever seen i like it i learn something today

  • Avatar

    If any business has to succeed, it is imperative that the employees work as a team. If the employees do not consider themselves a part of the team and are unable to work together, it would slow the whole company down. Similarly although competition between employees can be very important and beneficial for the company, if the competition reaches the point where it is hindering their work, something is wrong and it should be corrected. Scavenger hunt events can help with that.

  • Avatar

    Our mission is to provide clients the highest quality tattoo that the industry offers. We specializes in realistic, 3D, portrait, water color, and japanese tattoos. Our studio provides a professional and clean work environment that utilizes the latest state of the art sterilization procedures. We customize each design so your personal preferences can make your tattoo unique and very personal to you. The studio is fully licensed and located just a few blocks south of the Mall of America in Bloomington, Minnesota near the Minneapolis-St Paul International Airport. We are in the same building as the Eagles Club. While most of our works are done by appointment we also offer walk-ins based upon our availability. However, we suggest you call in to check availability prior to your visit.

  • Avatar

    Sound Dentistry Seattle provides the highest quality dental care in Downtown Seattle. Rick Nicolini DDS and his staff are committed to dental excellence and utilize the latest technology. We specialize in Zoom Teeth Whitening, simple to complex Implant Restorations, General, Preventative and Restorative Dentistry, Complete and Partial Dentures. We have our own in-house dental laboratory and technician. We are conveniently located near the Amazon campus in the Denny Triangle of Downtown Seattle. http://sounddentistry.com/

Add Comment

Text Only 2000 character limit

Page 1 of 8

[First] [Previous] [Next] [Last]